Love these Taylor Swift Songs? Try some Cather Classics!

Willa Cather’s novels, known for their deep exploration of human relationships and rooted in the American heartland, earned her a Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. Taylor Swift, similarly acclaimed with multiple Grammy Awards, has influenced culture to the point where her music is compared to classic literature, including Cather’s works.

My Antonia
"My Ántonia" by Willa Cather, a classic American novel from 1918, explores themes of immigration, frontier life, and pursuit of the American dream through the friendship of Jim Burden and Ántonia Shimerda on the Nebraska prairie. In Taylor Swift's music, especially in her early albums, themes of love, nostalgia, and growing up are prominent. While their settings differ, Swift's songs like "Mine" and "Mean" echo the perseverance and immigrant struggles found in "My Ántonia." Songs like "Long Live" and "Change" also reflect themes of personal growth and resilience. Though not direct mirrors, these songs share emotional elements with Cather's novel and could resonate with similar audiences. The character of Ántonia was inspired by Cather’s childhood friend Anna, who raised a large family on the Pavelka Farmstead, near Red Cloud

Taylor Swift Records, Cather Books
Pavelka Farmstead, My Antonia
Pavelka Farmstead, My Antonia

O’Pioneers
In “O Pioneers!,” love and relationships are explored, including an adulterous entanglement between young sweethearts Emil and Marie. In a fury of rage, Marie’s husband stumbles upon and violently murders the two lovers, who die in each other's arms. This adds depth to the novel's exploration of personal desires and societal outrages. Similarly, Taylor Swift's songs like 'Cardigan,' 'August,' and 'Betty' from her album 'Folklore' weave a tale of a love triangle. Through these songs, Swift captures the emotional complexities of love and longing, echoing the themes explored in 'O Pioneers!' Both the novel and Swift's songs resonate with audiences, delving into the intricacies of love and relationships, making them timeless works of art.

The Song of the Lark
In “The Song of the Lark,” Willa Cather tells the story of Thea Kronborg's pursuit of her opera career and her romantic endeavors. It follows the journey of a female artist with a strong sense of independence, much like the themes Swift sings about in her songs ‘The Man’ and ‘The Lucky One.’ Eventually, the lead character finds herself swept off her feet, reminiscent of Swift's song 'Lover,' which celebrates the depth and commitment of a romantic relationship amidst a fulfilling career. With its parallels to Taylor Swift's own life, this book offers an enjoyable read for fans and transports readers to tiny Moonstone, a fictional version of Red Cloud, Nebraska. The setting from the opening scenes of the book is reminiscent of the Willa Cather Childhood Home. A downtown opera house is also a backdrop in the novel, no doubt inspired by Cather’s childhood experiences at the Red Cloud Opera House.

Taylor Swift, Willa Cather, The Song of the Lark

A Lost Lady
Published in 1923, "A Lost Lady" by Willa Cather unfolds the narrative of Marian Forrester within the fictional setting of Sweet Water, Nebraska, a town situated in south central Nebraska. Through narrator Niel Herbert, it explores Marian's life, infidelity, and the changes in early 20th-century America. Taylor Swift's music also touches on themes of nostalgia and lost love.  While Swift describes an adulterous meeting in a parking lot in ‘Illicit Affairs,’ Cather writes of Marian Forrester’s sleigh ride liaison with Frank Ellinger. While not mirroring the plot, songs like "All Too Well" and "The Last Time" also capture emotions of heartbreak and longing, echoing the novel's bittersweet tone.

Taylor Swift, Willa Cather, A Lost LadyOld Mrs. Harris
“Old Mrs. Harris," a short story from 1932 by Willa Cather, portrays three generations of women, emphasizing compassion and familial sacrifices. Taylor Swift's song "The Best Day" echoes this sentiment, expressing gratitude for a mother's love and sacrifices. Both narratives celebrate family bonds and highlight the importance of empathy and compassion. In "Marjorie," Swift pays homage to her grandmother, resonating with the themes of love and legacy found in "Old Mrs. Harris." This short story is drawn from Cather’s own childhood experiences in Red Cloud, and her relationship with her mother and maternal grandmother. To this day, you can visit her Childhood Home there along with the Cather Second Home. Both Cather's timeless story about the impatience of youth and Swift's heartfelt song serve as poignant reminders of the enduring power of family and the legacies they leave behind. 

My Mortal Enemy
"My Mortal Enemy," a novella by Willa Cather from 1926, follows Myra Henshawe's journey as she confronts the consequences of her choices in a strained marriage. Taylor Swift's song "Tolerate It" from her album "Evermore" delves into the pain of unrequited love and feeling unnoticed in a relationship. Other songs like "Exile" and "The Last Time" explore themes of heartbreak and regret, echoing the emotional depth of Cather's narrative. Both Cather's novella and Swift's music offer insights into human emotions and relationships, resonating with audiences.

Lucy Gayheart
This 1935 novel centers on Lucy Gayheart, a young woman from the fictional town of Haverford along Nebraska's Platte River. Eager to pursue her passion for piano, Lucy leaves her small-town life behind to study in Chicago. There, she rejects a marriage proposal from an eligible bachelor from Haverford, drawn instead to the enigmatic and much older musician, Clement Sebastian. After a series of poignant experiences, Lucy returns to Haverford, where she confronts profound loss and regret, mirroring the themes of heartache and longing found Swift's newest album,  The Tortured Poets Department. The novel's haunting conclusion lingers in readers' minds, much like the evocative lyrics of Swift's songs.


In exploring the lives and careers of Taylor Swift and Willa Cather, a striking array of parallels emerges, underscoring the profound impact each has had.
Parallels drawn between the two:

  • Both individuals actively engage(d) in the marketing of their respective works.
  • Both Sagittarius.
  • Both write/wrote about real-life people and stories that can be linked to.
  • Both have fought for higher royalties and were protective of their creative products.
  • Both are/were prolific creators.
  • Both have graced the cover of Time Magazine, attesting to their cultural impact.
  • Both hold honorary Doctorate degrees.
  • Both have strong ties to New York City's Greenwich Village.

Looking for more insights into Willa Cather's life and work? The National Willa Cather Center’s mission is to enrich lives by advancing Willa Cather's legacy through education, preservation and the arts. A visit to the Center and Red Cloud offers fans the chance to explore significant historic sites. Opened in 2017, the National Willa Cather Center features a bookstore, exhibits, archives, and galleries. Additionally, the Foundation oversees the Red Cloud Opera House and the Willa Cather Memorial Prairie, spanning 612, preserving the untamed landscapes that inspired Cather's writing. Daily guided tours are available. Red Cloud provides various lodging options, including the historically meaningful Cather Second Home Guest House and Villa Willa Historic Loft Apartment, conveniently located on the upper floor of the same historic building housing the center. A perfect getaway for a Tortured Poet. Those seeking to hone their creativity should consider applying for the Willa Cather Residency Program, a two-week writers residency in Cather’s hometown of Red Cloud.

Cather Childhood Home
Willa Cather

Willa Cather

In 1962, Cather was inducted into the Nebraska Hall of Fame, and her bust is proudly displayed in the Nebraska State Capitol. From 1891 to 1895, she attended the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, where she embarked on her literary journey. Today, several locations around the Lincoln campus honor her literary legacy.